Chimo is a private monitoring and filing service and is not the court, the settlement administrator or a law firm.

The claim deadline passed on September 22, 2025. New claims for this settlement are no longer being accepted.
The court approved the settlement on October 22, 2025. Payments are sent once that approval is final: after the time for anyone to appeal it runs out, or after any appeal ends.
Then the payments go out. The settlement administrator, the firm the court appointed to process claims, sends payments to eligible claimants once it has reviewed the claims. How long that takes varies from one settlement to the next.
Filed this claim with Chimo? The status of your claim is on the claims page in your account.


Jeffrey Spindel sued Alderfer Family Farm LLC and Alderfer Poultry Farm, Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on December 8, 2023, saying that the companies falsely advertised their non-organic eggs as coming from "free-roaming" hens. According to the complaint, as the settlement agreement summarizes it, some Alderfer hens had only 1.2 to 1.6 square feet each indoors and minimal, quasi-outdoor access. Alderfer denies the allegations and any wrongdoing, and the court did not decide who was right.
The Non-Organic Eggs class action case centers on claims of consumer deception and false advertising under New York General Business Law sections 349 and 350.
Key lawsuit details:
Detail
Description
Allegations
Case number
7:23-cv-10710 (Spindel v. Alderfer Family Farm LLC et al.)
Settlement
$287,500 to resolve claims
Settlement documents & site
Official settlement website: AlderferSettlement.com
Eligibility
U.S. consumers who purchased Alderfer non-organic eggs between Dec 1, 2020, and final court approval, excluding those who already received full refunds
Key dates:
The claim filing deadline was September 22, 2025. New claims can no longer be filed.
The court granted final approval on October 22, 2025.
A $287,500 Non-Organic Eggs settlement resolved the lawsuit's claims that Alderfer falsely marketed eggs as “free-roaming.” Alderfer denies the allegations and any wrongdoing, and the court did not decide who was right. The settlement offered $2.00 per carton to eligible buyers of Alderfer non-organic eggs purchased since December 1, 2020, adjusted pro rata depending on the total of valid claims and capped at $3.00 per carton. The Non-Organic Eggs settlement eligibility covers U.S. household purchasers who did not already receive a full refund.
As part of the settlement, Alderfer stopped shipping eggs with the “free-roaming” language as of April 12, 2024, and agreed not to bring it back for 36 months from that date. Consumers without receipts could claim up to two cartons, while those with proof of purchase had no carton limit. The court granted final approval on October 22, 2025, and awarded class counsel $86,250 in attorneys' fees, $10,465.01 in expenses, and a $5,000 service award to Jeffrey Spindel. If funds remain after all claims and fees are paid, the balance goes to Animal Outlook, a nonprofit, for consumer education about egg industry practices.
The Non-Organic Eggs settlement amount per person depended on how many cartons a claimant could claim.
The settlement offered $2.00 per carton to eligible claimants, adjusted pro rata depending on the total of valid claims and capped at $3.00 per carton. Without proof of purchase, a claim was limited to two cartons, or $4.00 at the standard rate and no more than $6.00. With receipts, there was no carton limit.
How much could eligible class members receive from the Non-Organic Eggs settlement?
Claim Type
Payout
Without Proof
$2.00 per carton, up to two cartons (no more than $6.00 total)
With Proof
$2.00 per carton, adjusted pro rata and capped at $3.00, with no carton limit
The court granted final approval to the Alderfer Non-Organic Eggs false advertising settlement on October 22, 2025. Under the settlement agreement, the administrator was to begin paying approved claims ten days after the settlement's effective date.
Appeals can delay payments to eligible claimants. Questions about a payment go to the settlement administrator at Info@AlderferSettlement.com or 1-833-296-0891.
To meet Non-Organic Eggs class action eligibility, you had to have purchased Alderfer non-organic eggs labeled "free-roaming" between December 1, 2020, and final court approval. The claim form for Non-Organic Eggs class action claimants asked for:
Your name, address, and telephone number.
The quantity and type of eggs you bought.
The retailer you bought them from, with its city and state.
The approximate dates you bought them.
A claim also needed either a reasonable proof of purchase or a declaration, signed under penalty of perjury, of what you bought. Claims without proof were limited to two cartons.
Nationwide. The settlement covers people who bought the Alderfer non-organic egg products listed in the settlement in the United States, for personal or household use and not for resale, from December 1, 2020, on. Anyone who already received a full refund is excluded.
Animal Outlook is the plaintiff in a related lawsuit against Alderfer in Washington, D.C. (Animal Outlook v. Alderfer Family Farm LLC et al., No. 2023-CAB-007338). The settlement agreement says that lawsuit contributed significantly to bringing about the settlement conference in this case. The parties agreed that if money remained after paying claimants, attorneys, and administration costs, it would go to Animal Outlook, with the court's approval, to educate consumers about conditions in the egg industry.
Alderfer stopped shipping eggs with the “free-roaming” language on the packaging as of April 12, 2024, and agreed not to bring it back on packaging, websites or other marketing for 36 months from that date.
Yes, the claim process asked claimants to list the store location and approximate purchase date to verify eligibility.
These are the court's own records for this case. They are hosted here unchanged, so you can check anything on this page against the documents themselves.
The full case file is on the court docket: view the docket.
Chimo AI Inc. is a private company. We are not a law firm, do not give legal advice, and are not affiliated with or endorsed by any court, settlement administrator, defendant or government agency.