Claim Window Now CLOSED

West Bend Mutual Insurance Company Class Action Lawsuit

Updated
West Bend insurance settlement over labor depreciation that the lawsuit says was wrongly withheld from property damage claims in seven states.
See settlements you can still claim

Chimo is a private monitoring and filing service and is not the court, the settlement administrator or a law firm.

Person signing a document with an adviser – West Bend Mutual Insurance class action

What happens next with the West Bend Mutual Insurance Company settlement

The claim deadline passed on February 6, 2026. New claims for this settlement are no longer being accepted.

Payments come after approval, and after any appeals. Anyone who objected to the settlement can ask a higher court to look at it again — an appeal — and that has to finish first. Eligible payments are sent once approval is final, and the stretch from a claim deadline to money in hand often runs a year or more. It varies from one settlement to the next.

Filed this claim with Chimo? The status of your claim is on the claims page in your account.

2026 Class Action Settlements > West Bend Mutual Insurance Company Class Action

West Bend Mutual Insurance Company Class Action Lawsuit

West Bend property insurance policyholders sued over how West Bend worked out the first payment on claims for damage to a home or other building. That payment, the actual cash value or ACV payment, is the estimated cost to repair or replace the damage, minus depreciation (an allowance for the age and wear of what was damaged) and minus the deductible.
​
The lawsuit claims West Bend improperly depreciated the parts of a repair estimate that are not materials, such as labor, overhead and profit, which the settlement calls nonmaterial depreciation. The settlement ties this to option settings in Xactimate, the estimating software West Bend used, named "depreciate non-material," "depreciate O&P" and "depreciate removal." West Bend denied all of the allegations, and the court never decided who was right.
​
No Joke, Inc., brought the case (No Joke, Inc. v. West Bend Mutual Insurance Company, Case No. 2025-LA-0000153) in the Tenth Judicial Circuit Court of Peoria County, Illinois, on behalf of policyholders in Illinois, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio, Tennessee, Virginia and Wisconsin. Class counsel, the lawyers the court appointed to represent the class, are Erik Peterson of Erik Peterson Law Offices, PSC, Brandon McWherter of McWherter Scott Bobbitt PLC and T. Joseph Snodgrass of Snodgrass Law LLC. The court preliminarily approved the settlement on September 9, 2025, and a final approval hearing was scheduled for January 7, 2026.

Lawsuit Name
No Joke, Inc. v. West Bend Mutual Insurance Company
Court
Tenth Judicial Circuit Court of Peoria County, Illinois
Case Number
2025-LA-0000153
Judge
Presiding Judge, Tenth Judicial Circuit Court
Plaintiffs
No Joke, Inc., on behalf of similarly situated policyholders
Defendants
West Bend Mutual Insurance Company
Key Allegation
The lawsuit claims West Bend improperly deducted labor, overhead and profit depreciation from property damage claim payments.

West Bend Mutual Insurance Company Class Action Settlement - Uncapped

The West Bend settlement has no fixed fund and no cap on the total. Instead, West Bend agreed to pay eligible class members who filed a valid claim form by February 6, 2026, an amount worked out from West Bend's own claim records, so the total depends on how many people claimed and how much depreciation was withheld from each of them.
​
For a policy issued in Illinois, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio or Tennessee, the payment is 100% of the nonmaterial depreciation (the labor, overhead and profit part) that was withheld and never repaid; for Virginia or Wisconsin it is 80%. Both add simple interest of 5% a year from the date of the final ACV payment through July 1, 2025. Policyholders whose withheld depreciation was later repaid in full were eligible for a set amount instead, from $25 to $500 depending on how much was withheld.
​
Class counsel said they would ask for up to $1,392,500 in fees and expenses, and up to $7,500 for No Joke, Inc., for representing the class. West Bend pays those amounts, and the cost of running the settlement, separately, so they do not reduce what eligible class members are paid. A final approval hearing was scheduled for January 7, 2026.

Claims closed: February 6, 2026

West Bend Mutual Insurance Claims Class Action Payout: 80% to 100% of withheld depreciation

Each payment was worked out from West Bend's records for that claim, not from how many people filed. For a policy in Illinois, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio or Tennessee, it is 100% of the nonmaterial depreciation that was withheld and never repaid; for Virginia or Wisconsin it is 80%. Both add simple interest of 5% a year from the date of the final ACV payment through July 1, 2025. The same formula applies where withholding that depreciation dropped the loss below the deductible, so no ACV payment was made at all. Every payment is still subject to the policy's own limits and deductible.
​
Where West Bend later repaid all of the withheld depreciation, the payment is a set amount based on how much was withheld: $25 for up to $5,000.99, $50 up to $10,000.99, $100 up to $20,000.99, $200 up to $40,000.99, $300 up to $60,000.99, $400 up to $80,000, and $500 above $80,000.
​
Under the agreement, eligible payments are mailed as checks that expire 90 days after they are issued. A class member who disagreed with the amount, or with a denial, could ask for a neutral evaluator's review by returning the uncashed check with a written explanation within 30 days of the notice, and that decision is final. Where the interest part is large enough to be reported to the IRS, the administrator may ask for a Form W-9 before sending the check.

West Bend Mutual Insurance Claims Class Action Eligibility

The West Bend settlement covered anyone who had a personal or commercial property insurance policy from West Bend and made a claim for physical damage to a home, building, manufactured home, condo, rental dwelling or other structure in Illinois, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio, Tennessee, Virginia or Wisconsin. The date of loss had to fall between March 29, 2020, and June 30, 2022, or for Missouri between March 29, 2012, and June 30, 2022. West Bend also had to have used an Xactimate estimate and withheld nonmaterial depreciation from the ACV payment, or withheld enough that the loss fell below the deductible and no ACV payment was made.
​
Some claims that look similar were left out: claims under a policy form, endorsement or rider that expressly allowed labor depreciation using the words "depreciation" and "labor," claims where an ACV payment used up the policy limits, claims denied or abandoned for any other reason, and claims where West Bend never produced an Xactimate estimate.
​
The claim form was short, because West Bend checked eligibility and worked out each payment from its own records. It asked for the claimant's name and address, the insured's name, the policy and claim numbers, the property address and the date of loss, with a separate form for each loss. A legally authorized representative, or a contractor the claim had been assigned to before the settlement was preliminarily approved, had to attach written proof. The claimant signed to swear or affirm that the information was true and correct to the best of their knowledge. Claim forms were due February 6, 2026. New claims can no longer be filed.

You had a personal or commercial property insurance policy with West Bend Mutual Insurance.
You made a claim for damage to a home, building or other structure in IL, KY, MO, OH, TN, VA or WI.
Your date of loss was between March 29, 2020, and June 30, 2022 (in Missouri, from March 29, 2012).
You had a claim on which West Bend used an Xactimate estimate and withheld labor, overhead or profit depreciation from the payment.

FAQ

The lawsuit alleges West Bend improperly reduced property claim payouts by depreciating labor and other nonmaterial costs when calculating ACV payments.

The settlement is defined by specific option settings in Xactimate, the estimating software West Bend used: "depreciate non-material," "depreciate O&P" and "depreciate removal." The lawsuit claims those settings depreciated labor, overhead and profit, and the class covers only claims where West Bend produced an Xactimate estimate.

No proof of repairs was required. Eligibility was determined using West Bend's claim records and the claimant's claim form information.

Yes. They could still be eligible if depreciation reduced their claim below the deductible, resulting in no ACV payment at all.

The settlement provided 100% of the withheld nonmaterial depreciation for policies issued in Illinois, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio and Tennessee, and 80% for policies issued in Virginia and Wisconsin. Both add simple interest of 5% a year through July 1, 2025. Missouri also has a longer class period.

Yes, if the insurance claim was assigned to a contractor, such as a roofer, before the settlement was preliminarily approved. The contractor had to attach a written copy of the assignment and agree to cover West Bend's loss if the policyholder also filed or disputed the payment.

Policyholders could file a separate claim form for each eligible loss, and each loss was assessed on its own under the settlement's formula, using West Bend's records for that claim.

The settlement does not single out roofs. It covers any structural loss, meaning physical damage to a home, building, manufactured home, condo, rental dwelling or other structure, so roof damage to one of those counted if the other conditions were met.

The settlement gives Missouri claims a longer class period, with dates of loss from March 29, 2012, instead of March 29, 2020; both periods end June 30, 2022. The settlement documents do not explain why Missouri's period is longer.

If West Bend later repaid all of the withheld depreciation, the settlement provided a set amount based on how much was withheld, from $25 for up to $5,000.99 to $500 for more than $80,000. If only part was repaid, the amount was based on the part that was not.

CHIMO
Sign up for updates on new lawsuits
and unclaimed money opportunities
© 2026 Chimo AI Inc. - All rights reserved.

Chimo AI Inc. is a private company. We are not a law firm, do not give legal advice, and are not affiliated with or endorsed by any court, settlement administrator, defendant or government agency.

About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions